ABC News: Hazmat Explosion in Ohio Forces Evacuations. What You Need to Know - October 21

Lehrer score 70/100 (−12 loaded wording: [1:58]-[2:00] 'A massive hazmat emergency in Toledo, Ohio.' (anchor's own voice); −18 unnamed source/unsourced figure: [2:02] 'Thousands of people forced from their homes overnight' (figure given with no source; the only official zone detail in the clip is [2:06]-[2:08] 'A onemile evacuation zone was ordered')). Fixed scale: 90+ A, 80s B, 70s C, 60s D, under 60 F → C. Framing: Emphasis: urgency. Opens on 'massive' [1:58] and 'Thousands of people forced from their homes' [2:02], then the official's explosion warning [2:23]-[2:46]. Spin: mild alarm in anchor voice, but the safety guidance [2:50]-[2:56] is plain. One item in a multi-story roundup.

[1:58]-[2:00] 'A massive hazmat emergency in Toledo, Ohio.' (anchor's own voice); [2:02] 'Thousands of people forced from their homes overnight' (figure given with no source; the only official zone detail in the clip is [2:06]-[2:08] 'A onemile evacuation zone was ordered')

Splits: [2:23] official, on record: 'There is still concern that the tank um is emitting this chemical'

• Broken. Rule: loaded wording ([1:58]-[2:00] 'A massive hazmat emergency in Toledo, Ohio.' (anchor's own voice))
• Broken. Rule: unnamed source/unsourced figure ([2:02] 'Thousands of people forced from their homes overnight' (figure given with no source; the only official zone detail in the clip is [2:06]-[2:08] 'A onemile evacuation zone was ordered'))

Watch at ABC News

Same story: 13abc WTVG, Washington Examiner

How the grades work

Dispute this grade