From the Left · Read · October 22, 2026
Oct 22 ยท Judge limits DHS noncitizen-voter field operations in nine states
NPR: Federal judge restricts DHS field operations looking for noncitizen voters
Grade B (82/100). The order's reasoning, the USCIS whistleblower, DHS's and a USCIS official's responses and the plaintiffs' lawyer all quoted; one unattributed claim on how rare noncitizen voting is
B: Uses an unnamed source or unsourced number.
- Relies on an unnamed source or a number with no source (minus 18 points): States reviews and audits have consistently found voting by noncitizens to be extremely rare (no review or audit named)
Splits: The order's reasoning, the USCIS whistleblower, DHS's and a USCIS official's responses and the plaintiffs' lawyer all quoted; one unattributed claim on how rare noncitizen voting is
Same story: NewsNation, Fox News
More graded coverage
- This story from the left, center and right
- More from NPR: NPR describes the Manila arrival, planned talks with Xi and Putin, and a protest in the capital. (B)
- More from NPR: NPR has Zelenskyy calling the nearly four-hour talks constructive and Rubio calling them very productive. (A)
- More from NPR: NPR says the House may have the votes to impeach Hegseth, but not the two-thirds Senate needs to remove him. (B)
- Also graded October 22, 2026: Washington Examiner: Le Pen ally blames right-wing for riots because they 'undermined' law enforcers (F)
- Also graded October 22, 2026: The Hill: Virginia state Sen. L. Louise Lucas charged with public corruption (B)
- Also graded October 22, 2026: The Hill: Rising: WSJ reports Musk ordered Ukraine Starlink restraints (segment from 11:42) (F)
- Every NPR grade · Scores by outlet
- All stories from October 22, 2026 · Today's stories