From the Left · Read · October 29, 2026
Oct 28 ยท Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth fires Lt. Gen. Brett Sylvia, the Joint Staff's top planner, after a Pentagon official says he failed three polygraphs about leaking classified Iran and Ukraine war information, a claim other Pentagon sources dispute
CBS News: Hegseth fires Pentagon's top military planner over what official says were leaks to media
Grade B (82/100). CBS reports a Pentagon official's account of the polygraphs and the Justice Department referral, two other Pentagon sources who say the accusations are not true, Sean Parnell's statement and the Joint Staff's retracted thank-you note.
B: Uses an unnamed source or unsourced number.
- Relies on an unnamed source or a number with no source (minus 18 points): says Sylvia 'was coordinating the Iran battle plan' with no source, while Fox News quotes an official saying he was not a central planner of the war
Splits: CBS reports a Pentagon official's account of the polygraphs and the Justice Department referral, two other Pentagon sources who say the accusations are not true, Sean Parnell's statement and the Joint Staff's retracted thank-you note.
More graded coverage
- This story from the left, center and right
- More from CBS News: With one week until Election Day, President Trump is rallying in Texas Tuesday as the race for a seat in the Senate heats up (B)
- More from CBS News: 'This is the United Nations. This isn't your communist dictatorship,' U.S. Ambassador to the U.N. Michael Waltz said during a shouting match at the United Nations (B)
- More from CBS News: The Justice Department took steps to charge James Comey with leaking information earlier this month, court records show (A)
- Also graded October 29, 2026: Washington Examiner: Judge denies DOJ bid to isolate 20,000 California mail ballots (A)
- Also graded October 29, 2026: Washington Examiner: Amy Acton reacts to Ramaswamy Ad (B)
- Also graded October 29, 2026: The Megyn Kelly Show: Is it possible the GOP could lose a SOUTH CAROLINA senate seat? @MegynKelly and @MarkHalperin break down a shock new poll. (D)
- Every CBS News grade · Scores by outlet
- All stories from October 29, 2026 · Today's stories