The Country

How accurate is Bill Maher? 71% on 7 graded calls

Bill Maher is right on 71% of graded predictions on The Country's pundit scorecard: 5 correct and 2 wrong on 7 graded calls, No. 2 of 13 ranked pundits. Listed in the Left column.

Pundit scorecard

WRONG

“Tonight, I'm saying, I think it's over. ... I just think he's going to lose. ... It'll be tied on Election Day, as always it will. The polls will be tied, and then he'll lose. That's my prediction. We'll see.”

Source

Trump loses the 2024 presidential election

What happened: Trump won 312 electoral votes to Harris's 226.

Outcome evidence
CORRECT

“he is not going to be the democrat's candidate for president in 2024”

Watch at 00:00:06

Biden will not be the 2024 Democratic nominee.

What happened: Biden withdrew on July 21, 2024.

Outcome evidence
NOT GRADED

“Republicans will take control of Congress”

Source

Republicans win the House in the 2022 midterms

What happened: Republicans won the House, 222-213.

Outcome evidence

Not graded: obvious call.

NOT GRADED

“next year they'll begin impeaching Biden and never stop”

Source

The GOP House will impeach Biden starting in 2023.

What happened: The House opened an impeachment inquiry in Sept 2023 but never voted to impeach Biden; he isn't on the House's impeachment list.

Outcome evidence

An inquiry and an impeachment vote are two readings that grade differently.

NOT GRADED

“Biden will be a crippled duck when he goes up against the 2024 Trump carry Lake ticket”

Source

Biden will face a Trump-Kari Lake ticket in 2024.

What happened: Biden withdrew on July 21, 2024; the Trump ticket ran with JD Vance.

Outcome evidence

A joke, not a serious call.

NOT GRADED

“Republicans will take control of Congress”

Source

Republicans win the Senate in the 2022 midterms

What happened: Democrats kept the Senate, 51-49.

Outcome evidence

'Congress' is ambiguous on the Senate.

CORRECT

“Here's the easiest three predictions in the world. Trump will run in 2024. He will get the Republican nomination. And whatever happens on election night, the next day, he will announce that he won.”

Source

Trump runs in 2024 and wins the Republican nomination

What happened: Trump filed for 2024 (FEC candidate P80001571, 2024 cycle) and was the Republican nominee; he won 312 electoral votes.

Outcome evidence
NOT GRADED

“whatever happens on election night, the next day, he will announce that he won.”

Source

Trump claims victory regardless of the result

What happened: Trump won the 2024 election, so the 'whatever happens' case (claiming a win after losing) was never tested.

Outcome evidence

Trivially true as worded; the real claim never had its condition met.

NOT GRADED

“my prediction now last time i didn't even say hillary was going to win when most people did this time i do think biden's going to win by large numbers popular vote and even the electoral vote”

Source

Biden wins the 2020 presidential election

What happened: Biden won. Context only, not graded: popular vote Biden 81,283,501 (51.31%) to Trump 74,223,975 (46.85%), a 4.46-point margin; Electoral College 306 to 232 (FEC, Federal Elections 2020, pp. with national totals).

Outcome evidence

Not graded: obvious call.

CORRECT

“i think trump losing and then saying well we fought the good fight but the best man won and uh i'm telling my staff to graciously allowed biden to no he's never going to do that”

Source

If Trump loses, he will not concede graciously

What happened: Trump lost (FEC 2020) and never conceded; AP reported he 'made clear he would not concede' and refused to congratulate the winner.

Outcome evidence
NOT GRADED

“I'll tell ya, do you know who I think is going to be the nominee in 2024? Don Jr.”

Source

Donald Trump Jr. is the 2024 Republican presidential nominee

What happened: Donald Trump (not Trump Jr.) was the 2024 Republican nominee and won (FEC official 2024 results list Donald J. Trump (R)).

Outcome evidence

A warning that something is possible, not a committed forecast.

WRONG

“Once fascists get power, they don't give it up. You've got President Trump for life.”

Source

If Trump loses in 2020, he won't leave office

What happened: Condition met: Trump lost (Biden 306 EV to 232). Biden was inaugurated Jan 20, 2021, and Trump left office at the end of his term.

Outcome evidence
CORRECT

“I think he's going to get the nomination”

Source

Mitt Romney wins the 2012 Republican presidential nomination.

What happened: Romney was nominated at the 2012 RNC in Tampa on Aug 28, 2012 (National Archives 2012 Electoral College page lists Romney [R] as main opponent).

Outcome evidence
CORRECT

“Obama is going to beat him like a runaway sister wife”

Source

Obama beats Romney in the 2012 general election (conditional on Romney being nominated; condition met).

What happened: Obama won the 2012 election, 332-206 electoral votes (National Archives, 2012 Electoral College results).

Outcome evidence

Become a Founding Member. Founding members get pundit scorecards free forever.

We store your email (and your name, if you give it) only to contact you about The Country. It is not shared or sold. To be removed, ask through our contact form.

Follow us:
AboutWatchArchiveJoinContactRSS