FRANCE 24: Kremlin says 'ready' to resume 3-way talks with US and Ukraine mid-November

Lehrer score 46/100 (−18 unnamed source/unsourced figure: [0:07] 'could take place, we are hearing, in Abu Dhabi in November. That is according to a Kremlin foreign policy aid talking on state television in Russia.' (aide unnamed); −24 own-voice claim/analysis: [2:12] correspondent: 'so repeatedly show such ignorance or willful untruthfulness' ... [2:38] 'people like Marco Rubio seem to be saying such incoherent things is a source of deep concern.' (own-voice judgment of US officials, one claim); −12 loaded wording: [2:34] correspondent: 'he's regarded in Ukraine as a complete idiot.' (Witkoff; insult in reporter's voice, attributed only to 'Ukraine')). Fixed scale: 90+ A, 80s B, 70s C, 60s D, under 60 F → F. Framing: Emphasis: Ukrainian frustration and anger at Washington [2:01]-[2:43]; Russia framed via Ukrainians as 'absolutely intrigent' [0:52] (attributed: 'they see'). Correspondent's own contempt for US officials is the spin. Kharkiv voices [4:03] named only by role.

[0:07] 'could take place, we are hearing, in Abu Dhabi in November. That is according to a Kremlin foreign policy aid talking on state television in Russia.' (aide unnamed); [2:12] correspondent: 'so repeatedly show such ignorance or willful untruthfulness' ... [2:38] 'people like Marco Rubio seem to be saying such incoherent things is a source of deep concern.' (own-voice judgment of US officials, one claim); [2:34] correspondent: 'he's regarded in Ukraine as a complete idiot.' (Witkoff; insult in reporter's voice, attributed only to 'Ukraine')

Splits: [0:25] 'today the Kremlin declared that Putin might participate if numerous conditions are met.'

• Broken. Rule: unnamed source/unsourced figure ([0:07] 'could take place, we are hearing, in Abu Dhabi in November. That is according to a Kremlin foreign policy aid talking on state television in Russia.' (aide unnamed))
• Broken. Rule: own-voice claim/analysis ([2:12] correspondent: 'so repeatedly show such ignorance or willful untruthfulness' ... [2:38] 'people like Marco Rubio seem to be saying such incoherent things is a source of deep concern.' (own-voice judgment of US officials, one claim))
• Broken. Rule: loaded wording ([2:34] correspondent: 'he's regarded in Ukraine as a complete idiot.' (Witkoff; insult in reporter's voice, attributed only to 'Ukraine'))

Watch at FRANCE 24

Same story: Scripps News, New York Post

How the grades work

Dispute this grade