From the Left · Watch · November 4, 2026
Nov 4 · Why Republicans lost the midterms: Ron DeSantis calls it a rejection of Republicans in Washington, Sarah Matthews faults Karoline Leavitt's spin, and James Fishback asks what the GOP runs for
The Bulwark: .@SarahAMatthews1 reacts to Karoline Leavitt blaming the media for the GOP’s devastating midterm losses and suggesting Americans don't realize they're financially better off under Trump.
Grade F (46/100). Sarah Matthews reacts to a Fox News clip of Karoline Leavitt blaming the media for the GOP's losses and saying Americans are better off
F: Mixes in the reporter's opinion.
- Adds the reporter's own opinion or claims as fact (minus 24 points): [1:06] 'his war of choice with Iran that caused gas to absolutely skyrocket or his tariffs that he imposed that raised the cost of literally everything' (Sarah Matthews' own causal claims; no source)
- Relies on an unnamed source or a number with no source (minus 18 points): [0:52] 'more than $4 for a tank of gas, more than $6 for diesel, and paying up to $8 a pound for ground beef' (no source for the prices)
- Uses loaded words (minus 12 points): [0:36] 'Republicans got their asses handed to them' and [1:18] 'shellacked' (Matthews' own wording; the post adds 'devastating midterm losses')
Splits: Sarah Matthews reacts to a Fox News clip of Karoline Leavitt blaming the media for the GOP's losses and saying Americans are better off
Same story: C-SPAN, PBD Podcast
More graded coverage
- This story from the left, center and right
- More from The Bulwark: In 2018, @SonnyBunch warned Democrats not to waste their money trying to flip Texas. In 2026, he says it's a different story. After attending a Vance rally, Sonny explains why Republicans are pouring resources into a state they've dominated for decades. (D)
- More from The Bulwark: .@SarahLongwell25 on why this election should be a total repudiation of Trump: “It's time for Trump and for Republicans to feel the full weight of what they've done.” (D)
- More from The Bulwark: .@pennbarker reacts to Trump claiming he could have won the Vietnam War in a week: “Maybe focus on the war he's currently losing rather than one he never could have won.” (D)
- Also graded November 4, 2026: Washington Examiner: Mike Johnson won't run for minority leader (A)
- Also graded November 4, 2026: Washington Examiner: How shifting demographics helped Democrats flip the House and Senate according to exit polls (D)
- Also graded November 4, 2026: The Daily Caller: Susan Collins Faces Bruising Defeat To Troy Jackson In Maine Senate Race (C)
- Every The Bulwark grade · Scores by outlet
- All stories from November 4, 2026 · Today's stories