Center · Read · November 18, 2026
Nov 17 · Democrat Mary Peltola defeats GOP Sen. Dan Sullivan in Alaska, giving Democrats 56 Senate seats
CNBC: CNBC reports the AP call, the vote shares, and the Justice Department's appeal and criminal probe.
Grade C (77/100). Article: CNBC on Mary Peltola winning the Alaska Senate election
Lehrer score 77/100 (starts at 85; +2 one named, on-record source: Mary Peltola quoted on the record in a statement; +2 context: background or what came before: context: the Justice Department appeal and criminal investigation, and Scott Colom's Mississippi win six days earlier; −6 leaves out a fact or voice the other two pieces report / one side only (rule 5/13): leaves out that Peltola denied involvement in the second Sullivan's campaign, which NBC News and Fox News both report; −6 unlabeled claim, analysis or opinion in the outlet's own voice (rule 2/10): unlabeled analysis in the outlet's own voice: "perhaps the most stunning upset of the 2026 cycle"). Fixed scale: 90+ A, 80s B, 70s C, 60s D, under 60 F → C.
What we checked: leaves out that Peltola denied involvement in the second Sullivan's campaign, which NBC News and Fox News both report; unlabeled analysis in the outlet's own voice: "perhaps the most stunning upset of the 2026 cycle"
Splits: Article: CNBC on Mary Peltola winning the Alaska Senate election
Same story: NBC News, Fox News
More graded coverage
- This story from the left, center and right
- More from CNBC: CNBC reports the FAA router pause and quotes Sen. Ted Cruz that the full $50 billion won't pass. (A)
- More from CNBC: CNBC reports the arrival, quotes Xi via state media, and previews the Thursday agenda. (B)
- More from CNBC: CNBC reports the Army confirmed Tyner's identity and explains the two National Security Act sections. (A)
- Also graded November 18, 2026: Washington Examiner: The Examiner says Jeffries cemented his grip on the caucus and quotes ally Rep. Steven Horsford. (B)
- Also graded November 18, 2026: Washington Examiner: The Examiner quotes Hegseth calling Venezuela a compliant security partner but not Rodríguez. (C)
- Also graded November 18, 2026: Newsweek: Newsweek quotes the seven incoming progressives who explained why they voted no on Jeffries. (B)
- Every CNBC grade · Scores by outlet
- All stories from November 18, 2026 · Today's stories