The Country

From the Left · Read · November 21, 2026

Nov 20 · Appeals court rules the House's COVID-era proxy votes made the 2022 $1.7 trillion spending law unconstitutional

CNN: CNN notes the bill also carried about $45 billion for Ukraine and NATO allies and $40 billion in disaster aid.

Grade B (82/100). Article: CNN on the 5th Circuit ruling that the 2022 spending law was passed unconstitutionally by proxy vote

Lehrer score 82/100 (starts at 85; +3 primary document linked or cited (filing, ruling, data release, statement): cites the majority opinion by Judge Cory Wilson, including its "narrow scope" and the lack of an "existence of an emergency"; +4 other side quoted or given its response: the dissent: Judge James Graves says "no Member objected that a quorum was lacking"; +2 context: background or what came before: context: the 225-201 vote with 226 proxy votes and Texas' 2023 suit over the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act; −12 factual error or claim the piece can't support (cite the correct fact) (rule 3): says "a US district court judge made the same ruling in 2022"; the district court ruling came in February 2024). Fixed scale: 90+ A, 80s B, 70s C, 60s D, under 60 F → B.

What we checked: says "a US district court judge made the same ruling in 2022"; the district court ruling came in February 2024

Splits: Article: CNN on the 5th Circuit ruling that the 2022 spending law was passed unconstitutionally by proxy vote

Read at CNN

Same story: NBC News (Reuters), Washington Examiner

More graded coverage

How the grades work

Dispute this grade

Disagree with our approach or a rating? Have other feedback?

Tell us what you think we got wrong, or anything else. We read every message.

Become a Founding Member. Founding members get pundit scorecards free forever.

We store your email (and your name, if you give it) only to contact you about The Country. We never sell it. To be removed, unsubscribe from any email or write to [email protected].

Follow us:
About Watch Archive Join Contact Privacy Terms RSS