From the Left · Read · November 21, 2026
Nov 20 · Appeals court rules the House's COVID-era proxy votes made the 2022 $1.7 trillion spending law unconstitutional
CNN: CNN notes the bill also carried about $45 billion for Ukraine and NATO allies and $40 billion in disaster aid.
Grade B (82/100). Article: CNN on the 5th Circuit ruling that the 2022 spending law was passed unconstitutionally by proxy vote
Lehrer score 82/100 (starts at 85; +3 primary document linked or cited (filing, ruling, data release, statement): cites the majority opinion by Judge Cory Wilson, including its "narrow scope" and the lack of an "existence of an emergency"; +4 other side quoted or given its response: the dissent: Judge James Graves says "no Member objected that a quorum was lacking"; +2 context: background or what came before: context: the 225-201 vote with 226 proxy votes and Texas' 2023 suit over the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act; −12 factual error or claim the piece can't support (cite the correct fact) (rule 3): says "a US district court judge made the same ruling in 2022"; the district court ruling came in February 2024). Fixed scale: 90+ A, 80s B, 70s C, 60s D, under 60 F → B.
What we checked: says "a US district court judge made the same ruling in 2022"; the district court ruling came in February 2024
Splits: Article: CNN on the 5th Circuit ruling that the 2022 spending law was passed unconstitutionally by proxy vote
Same story: NBC News (Reuters), Washington Examiner
More graded coverage
- This story from the left, center and right
- More from CNN: CNN ties the order to Democrats' planned probes of the White House ballroom, DHS contracts and Starlink. (A)
- More from CNN: CNN notes Kash Patel touted FBI cybersecurity on Fox News after officials had learned of the breach. (D)
- More from CNN: CNN leads with the gunfire in Guasave and verified video of helicopters firing as people fled a stadium. (C)
- Also graded November 21, 2026: Washington Examiner: The Examiner frames the order as protection against "expected weaponization" by a Democratic Congress. (B)
- Also graded November 21, 2026: Newsweek: Newsweek traces Warren's months of pressure on Trump, from an April letter to regulators to her "I got the bill" offer. (A)
- Also graded November 21, 2026: Newsweek: Newsweek spells out the penalties: contract termination and possible debarment for companies that don't comply. (A)
- Every CNN grade · Scores by outlet
- All stories from November 21, 2026 · Today's stories