Read · November 20, 2026
Appeals court rules the House's COVID-era proxy votes made the 2022 $1.7 trillion spending law unconstitutional
The full 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 9-8 on Friday, Nov. 20, that the House unconstitutionally passed the $1.7 trillion 2022 government funding bill because it relied on pandemic-era proxy votes, which the majority said do not count toward a quorum under the Constitution's Quorum Clause. The bill passed 225-201, with 226 members voting by proxy. The court upheld an injunction Texas won that blocks the Justice Department and the EEOC from enforcing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, part of that bill, against the state. Judge Cory Wilson wrote for the majority; Judge James Graves wrote in dissent that the ruling is "illogical, inexplicable, and invalid." A Supreme Court appeal is expected.
- CNN notes the bill also carried about $45 billion for Ukraine and NATO allies and $40 billion in disaster aid.
"narrow scope"
Quoted in CNNGrade: B (82/100). Lehrer score 82/100 (starts at 85; +3 primary document linked or cited (filing, ruling, data release, statement): cites the majority opinion by Judge Cory Wilson, including its "narrow scope" and the lack of an "existence of an emergency"; +4 other side quoted or given its response: the dissent: Judge James Graves says "no Member objected that a quorum was lacking"; +2 context: background or what came before: context: the 225-201 vote with 226 proxy votes and Texas' 2023 suit over the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act; −12 factual error or claim the piece can't support (cite the correct fact) (rule 3): says "a US district court judge made the same ruling in 2022"; the district court ruling came in February 2024). Fixed scale: 90+ A, 80s B, 70s C, 60s D, under 60 F → B.
- The Reuters report on NBC stresses the relief is narrow: it bars enforcing the pregnant-workers provision only against Texas.
"the Quorum Clause's constraints on congressional power cannot be circumvented by congressional fiat"
Quoted in NBC News (Reuters)Grade: A (94/100). Lehrer score 94/100 (starts at 85; +3 primary document linked or cited (filing, ruling, data release, statement): quotes Judge Cory Wilson's majority opinion: "the Quorum Clause's constraints on congressional power cannot be circumvented by congressional fiat"; +4 other side quoted or given its response: Judge James Graves' dissent calling the ruling "illogical, inexplicable, and invalid," plus requests for comment to the DOJ and Paxton's office; +2 context: background or what came before: context: Pelosi's May 2020 proxy rule and its end when Republicans took the House). Fixed scale: 90+ A, 80s B, 70s C, 60s D, under 60 F → A.
- The Examiner quotes the majority on the Framers' quorum debate and A Better Balance warning women could be forced out of work.
"the Quorum Clause does not allow proxies to be included when establishing a quorum"
Quoted in Washington ExaminerGrade: B (86/100). Lehrer score 86/100 (starts at 85; +4 named, on-record sources (2+): named, on-record: A Better Balance President Inimai Chettiar and Sen. Mitch McConnell's amicus brief; +3 primary document linked or cited (filing, ruling, data release, statement): quotes the ruling: "the Quorum Clause does not allow proxies to be included when establishing a quorum"; +4 other side quoted or given its response: quotes the dissenting judges on why the judgment is limited to "one small sliver" of the bill; +2 context: background or what came before: context: what the law requires of employers, from water breaks to prenatal appointments; −12 factual error or claim the piece can't support (cite the correct fact) (rule 3): says the ruling "renders the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act moot" and "invalidates the law in Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi"; the court upheld an injunction barring enforcement against Texas only). Fixed scale: 90+ A, 80s B, 70s C, 60s D, under 60 F → B.
THREE TAKES. YOU DECIDE.
See it on the Read page · All stories from November 21, 2026 · How we grade · Previous story · Next story
Related stories
- The Supreme Court lets Trump resume border wall construction in Texas' Big Bend region, over Justice Jackson's dissent (Read, November 9, 2026)
- Trump orders federal contractors to clear congressional requests with the White House before Democrats take over (Read, November 20, 2026)
- Justice Department moves to drop its suit to block Peltola's Alaska Senate win (Read, November 19, 2026)
- Hegseth signs a deal restoring U.S. military ties with Venezuela on a surprise Caracas visit (Read, November 18, 2026)
- House Democrats nominate Hakeem Jeffries for speaker, 251-11 (Read, November 18, 2026)